Courts say one thing, cities do another. In limbo: the rights of the unhoused
Insights from authors of a new book on encampment rights. Plus: celebrating 6 months of De Facto
For years now, municipalities have been mostly left in charge of deciding how to treat unhoused people who have nowhere to be besides in public spaces.
In the absence of adequate housing for all — a fact recently recognized by Carney’s federal government which last week announced a 10-year-plan to “end homelessness” — the rights of unhoused people, who have no choice but to shelter outside, have been in limbo.
Today’s article interviews Alexandra Flynn and Joe Hermer, co-authors of The Bylaw State: Encampment Evictions and the Struggle for Public Space published this past spring.
They take us into a number of landmark court cases that establish unhoused people’s right to exist in public spaces, particularly when there is a lack of adequate housing for all.
Flynn and Hermer also explain how these court decisions often exist in a piecemeal fashion, only applying to the specific individual or encampment that raised the case.
“Until we have a decision that's made by the Supreme Court of Canada, a provincial case doesn't apply to all of Canada,” Flynn said.
Municipalities have also responded to court cases — like Victoria v. Adams in BC — by coming up with new bylaws that keep restricting unhoused people’s access to public spaces, while narrowly complying with the judgment.
“One response to the legal obligation that Adams laid out was that cities continued to ban sheltering in parks, but created “Temporary Overnight Shelters” (TOS) on specific sites, or created rules on where specific camping could take place,” Hermer said.
The interview addresses big questions like:
- whether court victories actually lead to lasting change
- whether housing challenges being met with bylaw enforcement is prudent
- what municipalities and other levels of government should actually be doing to ensure unhoused people’s Charter rights are respected.
Flynn and Hermer are quoted in De Facto’s recent two-part investigation in which we used AirTags to track new items that were donated to unhoused people living along downtown Victoria’s Pandora Avenue.
Now you can read the full interview with them in Q&A format here:

De Audio
Coming up this Saturday, don’t miss De Facto Radio’s latest show airing at 11 a.m. on CFO 100.5 Vancouver and livestreamed at Vancouver Co-op Radio!
This week, we’re celebrating our 6-month anniversary, with all 6 members of our worker-owned newsroom weighing in.
Hear a recap of our biggest stories, what we’ve loved and learned from in starting our own newsroom, and what we’re most excited about next.
You can also catch this and our other episodes so far on all major podcast platforms or at De Facto Radio’s webpage:




